Film details

The Reckoning  2001

Morality Play
Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Nicholas, training to be a priest in medieval England in 1390, leaves the priesthood after his affair with a married member of the congregation is discovered by her husband, and, in self-defence, Nicholas kills him, leaving the village and taking to the open road. On his travels he meets a troupe of travelling actors, their leader and mentor having just died and, after much discussion and some dissention within the group, Nicholas is allowed to join them. They arrive in a small town which is under the protection of their laird, Lord Robert De Guise. There is a clamour in the village where a local woman, Martha, a deaf mute, has been found guilty of murdering a young local boy, Thomas Wells. The players stage their Biblical performances but the villagers are distracted by the murder in their midst, so the troupe, now headed by Martin, decide to stage the circumstances of the murder as a drama to attract an audience. Nicholas and Martin go to the prison where Martha is being held and she, through gestures and mime, convinces them of her innocence. The players are staging the new drama and when they get to the subject of the murder the audience start to jeer and complain, revealing that four other young boys have also gone missing from the village. The troupe is told to gather their props and costumes and leave town. Nicholas is not convinced that the official record of how Thomas Wells died is accurate and digs up the recently interred body, discovering signs and marks of abuse and torture. He goes with these accusations to the King's Justice, one of the local law officials, who reluctantly reveals that it is believed that all the boys have been murdered, and that the local lord, Robert De Guise, is secretly suspected, but no one dares makes the accusation. Finding that Martha was convicted on the evidence of one man, a monk named Brother Simon Damian, Nicholas confronts him, demanding to know his connection to Robert De Guise, and Simon is found murdered shortly after their clash. The King's Justice tells Nicholas that Brother Simon's death collapses the case against the Lord, and that Martha's execution is to be carried out shortly. The troupe know they have to somehow prevent the death sentence being carried out and before her execution they start to perform a new piece of drama, one which tells the truth of the slayings and the identity of the culprit.

Production

Director
Paul McGuigan
Producer
Caroline Wood
Art Director
John Ralph
Editor
Andrew Hulme
Music
Mark Mancina, Adrian Lee
Screenplay
Mark Mills, based on the novel Morality Play by Barry Unsworth
Director of Photography
Peter Sova

Review

Director Paul McGuigan cannot be accused of taking the easy option, making the intelligent and frightening Gangster No.1 when British crime movies were, and were often worth, two a penny. The Reckoning, shot back in 2000 and only released in 2004, is another challenging project, adapted from his own stage play by Barry Unsworth. Essentially a detective story, and to be honest the identity of the real killer is rarely in doubt, this is a dark and grimy story, with every setting being gruesomely dirty and grotty, with a deep foreboding being set over the village and its' inhabitants. The idea of having strolling players essentially produce a drama concerning the events of the village is certainly not new, and was the only way most troupes made a living, but the staging of something which is obviously so raw to the villagers, and which also reveals that other young boys are also missing, is effective and uncomfortable. Death seems to be never very far away in the film, life being, as it was once surmised during the period, exceptionally nasty, brutish and short, but there is also a feeling that the plot does not transfer easily to film and that the stage, where the 'stagings' by the troupe would be at their best advantage, is perhaps the right medium for it. McGuigan has an excellent cast, used well, with particularly good performances from Paul Bettany as Nicholas, a character who is himself bloodstained albeit in self-defence, Willem Dafoe as Martin who assumes the leader's mantle, and the always impressive Vincent Cassel, almost reprising his role from Brotherhood Of The Wolf. A difficult and often complex film, The Reckoning is not an automatic crowdpleaser but shows that McGuigan is a director of intelligence, unafraid to tackle what is not immediately commercial material.