Film details
Max 2001
Hoffman
Still unavailable
Cast
-
-
Noah Taylor
-
Molly Parker
-
-
Ulrich Thomson
-
David Horovitch
-
Janet Suzman
-
Peter Capaldi
-
Kevin McKidd
-
John Grillo
-
Judit Hernadl
-
Janos Kulka
Synopsis
Max Rothman, the son of a wealthy Jewish family, has returned from the Great War having lost an arm, and now in the post-war peace of late 1918 has opened an art gallery in Munich. The loss of his arm has brought an end to his own artistic ambitions but he hopes by being a dealer to have some influence on the art scene. Hoffman seems to have a far better life than most of the rest of the German population, being not only comfortably well off but also seemingly happily married to his wife, Nina, but also has casual lovers and a mistress, Liselore Von Peltz. Several struggling artists come to Max with their portfolios, hoping to have him stage an exhibition or just offer advice. One of them is a young man called Adolf Hitler, like Max a war veteran who was gassed very badly while at the front. Max is not particularly impressed by the man's work but is intrigued by his single-mindedness and offers him encouragement. The Versailles Treaty is passed, putting tremendous burdens on Germany, which leads to a resurgence of nationalist feeling, even if the country is still ruined economically. Given to passionate political outbursts, Hitler is encouraged by fellow war veterans to get involved in political meetings, and proves to be a dynamic and compelling public speaker. He still harbours ambitions to have an exhibition mounted at Max's gallery, even though when he sees the modern art by artists such as Grosz and Otto Dix which Max displays he cannot hide his disgust, regarding their paintings as 'decadent'. Max still feels that Hitler could develop as an artist, even though Liselore takes an instant dislike to him when introduced, and warns Max that he is not to be trusted. Max finds a series of drawings Hitler has done, showing grand, imaginary buildings, huge in scale, and featuring the antique swastika symbol, and offers to try to find a buyer for them. Hitler appears at more and more political meetings and realises he is a far better orator than an artist. On the verge of abandoning his artistic endeavours for a career in politics, Hitler gets an invitation from Max to meet him at a luxury hotel to discuss the sale of his drawings. Hitler, wearing the ragged clothes which are never the less his best outfit arrives at the hotel early and waits for Max, who is late, but he does not know that his potential benefactor is lying unconscious in a gutter, having been attacked by a gang of neo-fascist thugs, some of the same men who responded so well to Hitler's oratory.
Production
- Director
- Menno Meyjes
- Producer
- András Hámori
- Art Director
- Tibor Lazar
- Editor
- Chris Wyatt
- Music
- Dan Jones
- Screenplay
- Menno Meyjes
- Director of Photography
- Lajos Koltai
Review
Although condemned by some pressure groups before production even started, writer and director Menno Meyjes, also the co-writer of the wildly different Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom, attempts something very different in putting Hitler into a pre-war historical context, and by inventing the fictional character of art dealer Max Hoffman, another excellent performance from the constantly interesting John Cusack, gives him a polar opposite - a fellow war veteran who is wealthy, socially adept, and a success with women, as well as being Jewish. The film isn't glib enough to suggest that had Hitler sold a few paintings then the Third Reich would not have ever happened but it does suggest a different path, that Hitler's rise was not inevitable but just the result of circumstances. The fact that the young Hitler was not exactly the most mesmeric man on the planet is well made and the film tries to find some indicators as to what made him what he became. Noah Taylor (Tomb Raider) gives an intense performance as the young Hitler, never overdoing the detachment and occasional violent outbursts, and the film never loses sight of the the most chilling fact of all - that Hitler was not some demonic creature from Hell, but an ordinary, mundane man.