Film details

The Life of David Gale  2003

Cast

Synopsis

Having arranged an extended Death Row interview with convicted rapist and murderer David Gale, three days before he is scheduled to be executed, journalist Bitsey Bloom and training intern Zack Stemmons travel to Texas, studying the facts of the headline case during the journey. David Gale was an ex-college professor and the author of such well regarded philosophical tomes as Dialogical Exhaustion, and was a major high-profile campaigner for the anti-death penalty pressure group Death Watch, Texas having the highest rate of executed prisoners in the USA. The head of Death Watch, Constance Harraway, was a close friend of Gale, and eventually became his victim. The two reporters meet Gale, who seems strangely calm despite his impending execution for a crime he insists he did not commit, and he fills them in on the details of how he came to be an innocent man on Death Row. After becoming friendly with Berlin, a young and attractive student, the two ended up having a passionate sexual liaison, and in turn Gale was accused of rape. The accusation caused him to lose his job at the University where he taught, his wife to leave him and Gale to eventually lose his family home, as well as having his drinking turn into self-pitying alcoholism. Having been scheduled for three days with Gale, they take the opportunity of a break to investigate the crime scene, the house where the body was found, Constance having died through asphyxiation, a plastic bag over her head. Forensic tests proved that the semen found within her was David Gale's. Having told Bitsey that he did not kill Constance, Gale adds the fact that she had leukemia, something which she told virtually no one else. Gale has also contributed to a live TV debate with the Texas Governor in charge of executions and offered a reprieve if he can name one executed prisoner who was probably innocent, but Gale finds he cannot. Returning to her hotel room Bitsey finds a video cassette waiting for her. When played it shows Constance, seemingly thrashing around in the last moments of her life. Zack mentions to Bitsey that he feels they are being followed, and they manage to identify their tail as Dusty Wright, another worker for Death Watch. On their next visit Gale admits that he had spent the night with Constance the night before her death and they had made love. Realising that there is no clear evidence of anyone else on the VHS tape, Bitsey surmises that Constance could have suffocated herself, perhaps in a bizarre suicide bid, knowing that David Gale would be sentenced for the murder which in Texas seemingly automatically receives the death sentence, and the tape would prove that he was not there. Believing that Dusty is involved with Constance's suicide Zack drives around the city, being followed by Dusty, allowing Bitsey to make a search of Dusty's house and find another VHS tape, showing Constance's suicide in detail. Realising this is the evidence that could save his life, Bitsey tries to get to the penitentiary just as Gale is being prepared for his execution...

Production

Director
Alan Parker
Producer
Nicolas Cage and Alan Parker
Art Director
Geoffrey Kirkland
Editor
Gerry Hambling
Music
Alex Parker
Screenplay
Charles Randolph
Director of Photography
Michael Seresin

Review

An emotive subject falls between two stools with Alan Parker's obviously impassioned The Life of David Gale, but a committed anti-death penalty message is negated by plot twists and repeated 'startling' revelations which would seem a little far-fetched in a cheap airport paperback thriller from a John Grisham imitator. Parker is obviously committed to the cause, and one of his finest films, Midnight Express, is also about a perceived miscarriage of justice, but here he seems caught between some very obvious targets (the Texas Governor is a George W.Bush look and sound-alike) and script twists which are handled with the dramatic subtlety of a Saturday morning serial cliffhanger. Kate Winslet (Titanic / Hideous Kinky) registers strongly until the last quarter, where all she has to do is run from location to location looking teary, while Kevin Spacey's contracts now seemingly include a clause that he has to get melancholic and cry at least once in every film. Obviously meant to be thought-provoking and aimed at stimulating debate, The Life of David Gale tries to sledgehammer its' audience with so many statistics and so much polemic that it almost becomes a university lecture in itself.