Film details

I Am Sam  2001

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Sam Dawson is a mentally retarded man living in California who reluctantly becomes a father after the woman carrying his child leaves the little girl with him after it is born and then abandons them both. Sam names the girl Lucy, after his favourite Beatles song, 'Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds', and raises her the best he can for the next seven years, help coming from a female neighbour occasionally. Sam takes care of Lucy and makes sure she goes to school and is a good student, but Lucy starts to falter at school and behave badly. Investigating the circumstances of her home life the school authorities and teachers become worried about her parenting arrangements, and believe that Lucy may simply now be cleverer than Sam and unable to regard him as a mentor and role model. Sam's limited capacities lead him into twice getting into trouble, once being involved with a prostitute and then accused of harassing a child, both of which are not his fault and are misinterpreted. Sam then finds the authorities have taken Lucy away and placed her in foster care. Sam has no legal representation so his friends put him in contact with Rita Harrison, a lawyer dealing with family matters and who eventually agrees to represent Sam free of charge. They become friends as well as lawyer and client, Rita finding that Sam has a surprisingly deep insight into human nature, and he helps her with advice over her failing marriage and her difficulty in communicating with her young son. Sam tries to keep down a job in a coffee bar but his worries over Lucy and his erratic habits cause him to lose the post, leading to him losing the court case. Sam is devastated but Rita convinced him not to give up hope. Rita helps him find a new apartment near to Lucy's new foster parents, and Lucy manages to see her dad as often as she can. Rita realises that with her help, and even though Lucy will still be with her foster parents, she can help Sam have a normal relationship with his treasured daughter once more.

Production

Director
Jessie Nelson
Producer
Jessie Nelson, Richard Solomon, Marshall Herskovtz and Edward Zwick
Art Director
Erin Cochran
Editor
Richard Chew
Music
John Powell
Screenplay
Kristine Johnson
Director of Photography
Elliot Davis

Review

Sean Penn treads a well worn path of actors trying to raise their screen profiles by portraying the handicapped, as shown with such performances as Dustin Hoffman's autistic character in Rain Man and Tom Hanks turn as Forrest Gump. Penn's Sam is actually the only sympathetic man in the cast, Rita's husband being the cause of most of the problems in her life, and the court officials, including the judge, being overbearing and insensitive. Indeed Penn's Sam looks positively saintly, ever ready with a piece of home-cooked advice or sparkling insight, but the sheer implausibility of the situation (would the authorities actually allow a little girl to grow up for seven years with a severely retarded single father - I don't think so) make this a gallery for Penn's nuances rather then satisfying drama.