Film details

The Cat's Meow  2001

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

As film producer Thomas Ince is buried in Los Angeles in 1924, writer Elinor Glyn recalls the circumstances of his death, on a cruise from Los Angeles to Santiago, when he was one of a party hosted by the powerful and ruthless press baron William Randolph Hearst on his yacht. Hearst was in his late fifties but had taken a young mistress, actress and comedienne Marion Davies, who Hearst was determined to launch as a serious dramatic actress in the films his company produced, despite her obvious gift for comedy. Also on the yacht as Hearst's guests are Margaret Livingston, herself Thomas Ince's mistress, several writers for Hearst's newspapers, including Louella Parsons, a gossip columnist whose reputation is growing, and comedy star Charlie Chaplin, his taste for very young woman leading to him to being obsessed with Davies. Parsons realises that this is a chance to advance her career, and Ince, whose films have not recently been successful, wants to form a production company with the vastly wealthy Hearst. Elinor Glyn realises how seriously Chaplin is flirting with Davies and warns her about him and his reputation. An article in a newspaper which is not one of the wide-ranging Hearst stable makes insinuations about Davies and Chaplin, a situation exploited by Ince who seeks to turn the situation to his advantage, the aging Hearst becoming consumed by jealousy and rage, seeing their behaviour together at a party to celebrate Ince's birthday as evidence of Davies' infidelity. Ince steals an unfinished love letter from Chaplin's cabin and shows it to Hearst, hoping to convince him that this shows how suitable and loyal he would be as a business partner but it is a gesture too far and Hearst bursts into Davies' cabin, wrecking it in the search for more evidence and then strides out on deck carrying his revolver, behaviour witnessed by Louella Parsons. Marion Davies tells Chaplin that she is flattered by his attention and is tempted by him, but won't leave Hearst for him, not knowing that Ince is outside the cabin, eavesdropping. Chaplin reluctantly leaves, Ince waiting outside the cabin, but Hearst is in the corridor and in the semi-darkness mistakes Ince for Chaplin, shooting him in the head. Parsons is once again a witness. Ince is not dead but is severely wounded and the yacht turns back to San Diego, docking the next morning where Ince is taken to a Los Angeles hospital. Hearst phones Ince's wife and tells him he attempted suicide, and manages to convince the other guests, through intimidation, that nothing untoward happened. Ince dies two days later, Parsons securing a cast-iron lifetime contract on Hearst's papers in order to secure her silence. Ince's death is put down to heart failure and is never formally investigated.

Production

Director
Peter Bogdanovich
Producer
Kim Bieber, Carol Lewis, Dieter Meyer and Julie Baines
Art Director
Christian Eisele
Editor
Edward Norris
Music
Ian Whitcomb
Screenplay
Steven Petos, based on his own stage play
Director of Photography
Bruno Delbonnel

Review

Having in later years become a friend of director Orson Welles, writing at length about this lost and wayward genius, that he should try to revisit some of the territory covered by Welles in his masterpiece Citizen Kane seems an obvious move by director Peter Bogdanovich, a director whose indulgence with the movies after such award winners as The Last Picture Show and Paper Moon manifested itself in such self-important disasters as Nickelodeon and the unspeakable At Long Last Love, the film which effectively killed his career, not that too many mourned, such were the number of mortal enemies Bogdanovich made on his rise to fame. Based on a genuine incident, for which there are several interpretations, Hearst managing to assure that the truth never emerged through a mixture of bribes and threats, the film has a terrific cast of characters, some stymied by truly bizarre casting choices. The beefy Eddie Izzard as the slight, small Chaplin, and equally stocky Edward Herrmann as the stooped, slim Hearst just seem perverse, especially considering Izzard's weird take on Chaplin. It is left to Kirsten Dunst to repair some of the damage by playing Marion Davies, an actress who it can be said had her career ruined by becoming Hearst's mistress, the benefactor insisting on putting her in his company's stodgy period dramas, Dunst showing the vivaciousness which so attracted Hearst to Davies. The plot, as envisaged here, goes together well, with Louella Parsons (the terrific Jennifer Tilly) securing her future by being a witness to the events, and the real Parsons became the highest-paid gossip columnist in Hollywood, living and working into her eighties. The events of what truly happened will never be known, but can be guessed at, but Bogdanovich mishandles both the tone and the pace, making it difficult for anyone to get too involved in what happened between a band of not particularly pleasant people. Bogdanovich has opined that The Cat's Meow should play in repertory cinemas on a double bill with Citizen Kane, since both deal with the character of William Randolph Hearst, an opinion which would be laughable were it not so offensively risible.