Film details

The Human Stain  2003

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Coleman Silk, a Professor of Classics at a prestigious university in Massachusetts, notices that a couple of students are consistently absent from his lectures and jokingly asks the assembled students if they actually exist or are they just spooks? His comment is reported back to the faculty who accuse him of using racist terms, Silk insisting that he was just questioning whether or not the students existed or were just ghosts or phantoms. He is forced to stand down and leave his post. His wife Iris, who has not been in the best of health, dies suddenly, Silk blaming the college and its' actions for her death. Feeling hurt and bitter, Silk contacts the reclusive and publicity-shy writer Nathan Zuckerman and tells him what has happened, Zuckerman being known for his involvement with various injustices. Zuckerman agrees to write an account of the affair and get it published in an influential journal, the two men becoming friends as Silk tells his story. Silk meets Faunia Farley, a woman thirty years his junior, whose waitressing job is only one of the three that she has. The two become friendly and Silk discovers that Faunia is no stranger to tragedy, having never fully recovered from the trauma of the death of her two young children when their house burned down. She also has a dangerously violent and unstable ex-husband, Lester, a Vietnam War veteran who now terrifies her with his volatile and explosive bouts of temper and rage. The two become close despite their difference in age, but Silk has deep secrets he thinks he can never tell Faunia. Pretending to be Jewish, Silk is in fact a very light-skinned African-American, and invented his background, not even his late wife knowing the truth. He knows that to reveal his heritage would have saved his job at the college, and spared himself the enmity of his colleagues, who were previously his friends before the racism allegations were made, but didn't. With he and Faunia now lovers he decides to unburden himself of the secrets and denials he has kept within him for years, and tells her everything. Faunia accepts Silk for what he is, not what he has to pretend to be, but as they are driving home that evening, they find they are being followed along the icy roads by a car being driven by the jealous and dangerous Lester...

Production

Director
Robert Benton
Producer
Tom Rosenberg, Gary Lucchesi and Scott Steindorff
Art Director
David Gropman
Editor
Christopher Tellefsen
Music
Rachel Portman
Screenplay
Nicholas Meyer, based on the novel by Philip Roth
Director of Photography
Jean-Yves Escoffier

Review

Written in 2000, Philip Roth's The Human Stain was inspired by a piece of political correctness which would be laughable were it not so genuinely worrying, when an American local Government worker was fired for using the word 'niggardly', meaning frugal or mean. That those who condemned him did not even know the real meaning of the words to which they so objected struck Roth as a good starting point for a book and while the adaptation of the book is very faithful, the filmic form means that several minor characters, including the writer Zuckerman and the vicious Lester Farley, are pared down severely. Nicholas Meyer's script and Robert Benton's direction are obviously sincere but there is a huge problem in transferring the character of Coleman Silk from the printed page to the screen, and casting such a high profile actor as Sir Anthony Hopkins also hampers the audience's belief in the character. Nicole Kidman too is just too delicate and glamorous, even in the film's idea of her as 'dowdy', as Faunia, a woman in the book battered by everything form her violent ex-husband, the loss of her children and having to keep down three jobs. Roth's book is ambitious and timely, but the scale of the topics involved, from political correctness to the secrets which one chooses to keep from the ones we love, are perhaps too big a canvas to transfer to the big screen, the casting problems in making Coleman Silk believable being just another obstacle.