Film details

The Man who Sued God  2001

Film still

Cast

  • Billy Connolly
  • Colin Friels
  • Bille Brown
  • Wendy Hughes
  • Blair Venn
  • John Howard
  • Emily Browning
  • Vincent Ball
  • Tim Robertson
  • Linal Haft
  • Peter Whitford

Synopsis

Steve Myers is a middle-aged fisherman, living in Whaleboat Bay, Australia and making a living fishing the abundant waters in the bay. Once a successful lawyer he gave up his position after becoming jaded with the legal world, and now spends his time either drinking or fishing, being divorced from his ex-wife Jules, who now lives with Les, who runs the caravan park where Steve lives, taking with her Steve's eleven year old daughter Rebecca. Heavily in debt and hoping to raise some money, Steve is enraged when his boat is destroyed by lightning during a storm and when he claims on his insurance policy the company refuse to pay up, citing 'Act of God' for which they are not responsible. Furious, Steve decides to launch a legal action against God, or since God can't represent himself in court, his representatives on Earth, sending writs to the cardinals, rabbis and bishops representing the major religions. Jules thinks Steve has finally gone mad but Rebecca supports her father's desire for justice. The media gets hold of the story, turning Steve into a minor media personality, despite his abrasive nature, and Anna Redmond, a reporter, becomes interested in both the case and Steve himself, and agrees to help in any way she can. David Myers, Steve's brother who failed his bar exams, is less willing to aid his cause. After a meeting to decide on what to do about Steve's action, the churchmen hire Gerry Ryan, a famously unscrupulous lawyer to represent them, while Steve finds his legal case changed to a 'class action' after hundreds of others who have been cheated by the 'Act of God' clause join the law suit, turning Steve into a Robin Hood character. Ryan starts to live up to his reputation by digging up both Steve's erratic past with the aid of David Myers and releasing smears against Anna, while also threatening to drag Steve's ex-wife and daughter into the media spotlight. Realising that this own brother is campaigning against him, and fearing what involvement in the case will do to Jules and Rebecca, Steve decides to withdraw from the proceedings but win a moral victory by claiming the case cannot go ahead since God does not exist, but on the day on which he is preparing to make his final speech before withdrawing, events occur which can only be put down to an Act of God....

Production

Director
Mark Joffe
Producer
Ben Gannon
Art Director
Juliet John
Editor
Peter Barton
Music
David Bridie
Screenplay
Don Watson, based on an original screenplay by John Clarke, based on an original idea by Patrick McCarville
Director of Photography
Peter James

Review

Although very much set up as a traditional underdog story, in which a downtrodden heroic figure battles against 'the establishment' and eventually triumphs, or at least as far as such an abstract concept as suing God can allow, Mark Joffe's The Man Who Sued God veers dangerously close to jettisoning its' script in favour of just becoming a vehicle for Billy Connolly, and he's well suited to the character of Steve Myers, once an upright citizen now a drop-out with a temper, bursts of seriously bad language, a weakness for the bottle, and one is tempted to see Connolly's own life and newly-found stardom as Steve Myers' life in reverse. Inevitably the supporting characters have to work hard to keep up with the lead, although the excellent Judy Davis (My Brilliant Career / Who Dares Wins) impresses as the cynical reporter seeing something genuine and impassioned in Myers, and Bille Brown's hideous lawyer Gerry Ryan is an all too believable characterisation. Joffe's film is smart and clever, even if its' barbs against the insurance industry and its' scams are unfortunately blunted through the aims of entertainment, but its' ace in the hand is Connolly, and everything revolves around him.