Film details

Evelyn  2002

Film still

Cast

  • Aiden Quinn
  • Julianna Marguilies
  • Stephen Rae
  • Alan Bates
  • Sophie Vavasseur

Synopsis

Desmond Doyle is an Irish father of three living in Dublin in the 50s. With a drink problem hampering him getting work as a painter and decorator, his wife leaves the family, and almost immediately his children are taken away and put into care, aided by the Catholic Church. His young daughter Evelyn is seperated from his sons Dermot and Maurice. Raising some money singing in pubs with his father, Henry, Doyle is at a loss knowing what to do, and even considers breaking into the orphanages, until Bernadette Beattie, a barmaid, introduces him to her brother, Michael, an influential lawyer. Desmond explains his situation to Michael Beattie, who warns him that even if the case gets to court he has virtually no chance of winning, but nevertheless takes the case, also utilising the services of Nick Barron, an Irish-American who deals in family law, and the pair go on to also recruit Tom Connelly, a lawyer who was once a rugby player who maintains the drinking habits of the sport, and who is also a specialist in family matters. As the three prepare the case, Desmond becomes close to Bernadette, but she is also being romanced by Nick Barron, who promises to take her back with him to America when he returns. Desmond's world also suffers another blow when his father suddenly dies. The case gets to court and the first hearing goes badly for Desmond when his personal circumstances and problems are revealed and examined, but he and the legal team take the case further, to the Supreme Court. At the next hearing one of the main witnesses is Sister Brigid, a nun at the orphanage which is taking care of Evelyn and, even though she has never met Desmond, gives a damning testimony against him. The last witness is to be Evelyn herself, and it is in her testimony that both the children's and Desmond's own future hangs.

Production

Director
Bruce Beresford
Producer
Pierce Brosnan, Beau St.Clair and Michael Ohoven
Art Director
Ian Bailie
Editor
Humphrey Dixon
Music
Stephen Endelman
Screenplay
Paul Pender
Director of Photography
Andre Fleuren

Review

Although based on a true child custody case which occurred in the Fifties, the eventual outcome is obvious from the beginning in this sentimental drama by Bruce Beresford (The Adventures of Barry McKenzie / Breaker Morant), reuniting him with producer and star Pierce Brosnan, with whom he previously worked on Mister Johnson. Essentially for all its' mild swipes at the over-zealous social services and the Church, The Magdalene Sisters this isn't. For a man with such a reputation for hard drinking, Pierce Brosnan's Desmond looks in pretty good shape, and with perfect hair, for such a reputedly shiftless character, and the legal trio of Stephen Rae (The Crying Game) Aiden Quinn (Avalon) and Alan Bates, playing it very wide as the ex-rugby player with a fondness for the black stuff, are all just this side of beatification. Very predictable and overwhelmingly sentimental, this will never the less fit the bill for a modern-day weepie, a genre they don't turn out too many of nowadays...