Film details

Bowling for Columbine  2002

Film still

Cast

  • Michael Moore
  • George W. Bush
  • Marilyn Manson
  • Matt Stone
  • Richard Castaldo

Synopsis

On April 20th 1999, students Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold entered Columbine High School where they both were pupils and killed thirteen students and teachers before turning their guns on themselves. Using their rampage as his springboard, writer and broadcaster Michael Moore looks at the gun culture of the USA, comparing it to that of Canada, which has a similar percentage of households owning guns but has a minuscule rate of firearm-related homicides when compared with their neighbour - 168 in the year 2000 compared with 11,127 in the US. On the basis that the Second Amendment allows its' citizens to bear arms not only to defend themselves but also to take on their own government in times of rebellion Moore visits the Michigan Militia, a heavily-armed band of supremicists who dream of civil disobediance and insist that carrying a gun is a duty rather than a right. Visiting an arms fair, Moore interrogates a spokesman for arms and missiles manufacturers Lockheed-Martin, who insists that their weapons are bought for defence purposes only. The 'shock-rock' star Marilyn Manson, real name Brian Robbins, of whom Klebold and Harris were devoted fans, claims that he and his music have been made scapegoats for teenage crime, insisting that he cannot be responsible for the actions of anyone deluded enough to act out the violence and cruelty of which he sings. Moore postulates the theory that since Klebold and Harris went bowling the morning before their killing spree in the afternoon, why not blame the evil influence of bowling? With many blaming the media and violent TV programming for the culture of violence which seems to have permeated America, sociologist Barry Glassner agrees that the American media has fostered a culture of fear. For relief Moore talks to South Park co-creator Matt Stone about violence in the media before looking at the case of Kayla Rolland, a six year old white girl shot dead by a black classmate, the child having found a gun in the crack house where he was left in the evenings while his mother travelled miles to work as a waitress under the Bush administration's Welfare-To-Work doctrine. To show the availability of guns in America Moore visits a bank which offers a hunting rifle with every new account opened. Telling the manager he wants the account for the free gun rather than any fiscal benefits, the manager is perfectly happy with his application. After meeting Columbine survivor Richard Castaldo, wheelchair-bound after being shot in the massacre, Moore takes him to the headquarters of the giant K-Mart supermarket chain and manages to persuade the chain to stop selling ammunition in their stores. Moore manages to secure an interview with actor Charlton Heston, the president of the NRA, the National Rifle Association, who refuses to believe that the proliferation of guns in the USA has anything to do with the hugely high rate of gun-related deaths. Heston is willing to be interviewed holding his favourite rifle, but when Moore's questions about gun ownership and the deaths of innocents become too uncomfortable, Heston ends the interview.

Production

Director
Michael Moore
Producer
Michael Moore, Kathleen Glynn, Jim Czarnecki, Charles Bishop and Michael Donovan
Editor
Kurt Engfher
Music
Jeff Gibbs
Screenplay
Michael Moore
Director of Photography
Brian Danitz and Michael McDonough

Review

Although of course editing will always be on his side, Bowling for Columbine is powerful stuff, despite a surprising number of elements playing against it. Michael Moore has both a touchy-feely personality which can be queasy, and an annoying habit of diversifying into detours which have little to do with the matter in hand - such as the pretty pointless discussion with South Park's Matt Stone - but the sheer discomfort which his subjects exhibit when he asks his barbed questions is sometimes painful, but to reinforce his point some of them involved, such as the bank manager very willing to hand a hunting rifle to any new account holder, appear genuinely not to understand the enormity of what they are doing, and shamelessly espouse firearms. Of course certain scenes work better than others, and Richard Castaldo's sequence is extremely powerful, while the much-touted interview with Charlton Heston (once a noted liberal) is a disappointment, Heston terminating the interview when he realises it is not just a PR stunt for the NRA. One can complain about Moore's manipulative methods, but the true fact is that the Michigan Militia, for all their stupidity and bigotry, are actually some of the least dangerous people in the whole production.