Film details

Carnage  2002

Carnages
Film still

Cast

  • Raphaelle Milinier
  • Jeanne Lucia Sanchez
  • Chiara Mastroianni
  • Clovis Cornillac
  • Jacques Gamblin
  • Esther Gorintin
  • Lio
  • Maryline Even
  • Bernard Sens
  • Pascal Bongard
  • Feodor Atkine

Synopsis

As Victor, a promising young matador, takes on a bull in the ring, he manages to deliver the fatal strikes but a momentary lapse of concentration means that he is badly gored by the dying beast and goes into a coma. The dead bull is butchered and its' parts sent around Europe, to various people in Spain, France and Belgium, but the ears, the most treasured parts indicating a matador of great skill and bravery, are kept for Victor for when he comes out of his coma. The horns are sent to an old woman who gives them to her son Luc. The eyes are sent to Jacques, a researcher in a hospital in Brussels. He examines the eyes and finds that one of them is blind, meaning that the bull was at a severe disadvantage when it entered the corrida. Jacques' wife Betty is in the last stages of pregnancy, having not told Jacques that she secretly underwent a course of fertility treatment. In Lille, the parents of Winnie, a five year old who suffers from severe epilepsy, buy one of the bull's bones from a supermarket to give to the family dog, being served in the store by Carlotta, a struggling actress who is working in the supermarket to support her sporadic acting roles. In the supermarket car park their trolley accidentally rams into Carlotta's car, damaging the paintwork. They leave without telling her, but accidentally leave a bottle of Winnie's medicine at the scene of the accident. Carlotta and her friend Alexis, an ice skater fighting suicidal thoughts, discover the medicine bottle and, finding the address on the pharmacy label, go to confront Winnie's parents. As they reach the house and are invited in, the family's Great Dane, Winnie's much loved pet, keels over dead. Having received the horns from his mother, Luc decides to act on a hunch, believing that an elderly man who lives locally is in fact his long estranged father whom he had been told was dead. Confronting the old man he finds that his deduction was true and the two embrace, but in a bizarre accident Luc seems to be impaled on the bull's horns he is still holding. Jeanne, a schoolteacher in France, travels to Spain to visit her ailing mother, Alice. Taking her to a restaurant Jeanne is surprised and confused when a stranger addresses her mother as 'Juliette', and she seems to sheepishly respond to that name. Jeanne is still confused when they leave the restaurant and, her mind occupied, she walks into the road and is hit by a police van. Recovering in hospital, her mother confesses to her daughter that although now known as Alice her real name is Juliette, having changed it when she killed her best friend, something she has withheld from Jeanne for decades. Alice's condition worsens and she dies, Jeanne agreeing to allow her organs to be used for transplantation, and Alice / Juliette's healthy liver is to be used to help a matador who was severely gored, a young man called Victor....

Production

Director
Delphine Gleize
Producer
Jerome Dopffer
Art Director
Andre Fonsny
Editor
Francois Quiquere
Music
Eric Neveux
Screenplay
Delphine Gleize
Director of Photography
Crystal Fournier

Review

Director Delphine Gleize has received praise and awards for her short films, but her two and a quarter hour debut feature strained the critic's patience when it showed in the Un Certain Regard sidebar of the 2002 Cannes Film Festival. The film, which boasts both Angela Molina (Pedro Almodovar's Live Flesh) and Chiara Mastroianni (La Reine Margot) in the cast, revolves around bizarre and unwieldy plot strands, the dividing up of the bull and its' despatch to a variety of people, but there seems to be no connection between anyone in the film, as if this were a selection of vignettes very loosely held together by a contrivance rather than a plot. The director has gone on record as saying that scripts are 'the last thing I have respect for', and that is a quote which could come back to haunt her when a film is as clumsily constructed as this, with Luc's impilation scene being only one example of the strange and peculiar construction and editing. Luc seems to have been the victim, but is later seen alive and well, as is the man who proves to be his father, so just who got skewered? Gleize has an eye for a bizarre setting or an eye-catching visual, such as Carlotta having to take a role as a pantomime cow in an amateur production for the experience, but until she starts to realise that without scripts films are just assembled footage she should stick to the short form rather than put an audience through 132 minutes of seemingly unrelated scenes and plots which go nowhere.