Film details

Taking Sides  2001

Der Fall Furtwangler / Taking Sides - Le Cas Furtwangler
Film still

Cast

  • Moritz Bleibtreu
  • Stellen Skarsgard
  • Birgit Minichmayr
  • Ulrich Tukur
  • Oleg Tabakov
  • Hanns Zischler
  • Armin Rohde
  • R.Lee Ermey
  • August Zimer
  • Daniel White
  • Thomas Thieme

Synopsis

With Germany occupied by the Allies after the end of World War II, Major Steve Arnold, an American officer previously an insurance fraud investigator, is assigned the case of Dr. Wilheim Furtwangler, the conductor of the Berlin Philharmonic orchestra, to see if there was collusion between Furtwangler and the Nazis. Arnold has two assistants, Emmi Straube, whose father was a senior Nazi officer who was executed for his role in the ill-fated assassination attempt on Hitler, and Lieutenant David Wills, a German Jew who was sent to America before the war started and spent his adolescence there. Arnold interviews members of the orchestra, who tell him that the conductor was not a member of the Nazi party, but did play for them on one occasion, with Hitler himself in the audience, but they stress that this was only done under the greatest duress. The American is not convinced, seeing Furtwangler as a collaborator who prospered under the Nazis, and his position as the conductor of the Berlin orchestra was the most prized post in the world of German classical music. He is brutally rude to him, asking probing, personal questions and calling him 'the devil's bandleader'. Furtwangler argues that he was devoted to his music and believes that art and politics are two different entities and cannot be mixed. When asked why he didn't leave Germany before the war started he tells Arnold that he did not want to leave the land of his birth. He claims not to have known what was happening in the death camps, but this jars with associates telling Arnold that Furtwangler saved many Jews from deportation on the death trains. Arnold feels frustrated in his mission, being unable to get the intelligent Doctor to incriminate himself, and knows that he is also using legal technicalities to try to improve his claims of innocence. Choosing to meet an informer from within the orchestra ranks, Arnold hears of Furtwangler's anti-Semitic remarks, few though they were, and of his affairs and complicated love life, which could have provided material for blackmail. The snitch also tells Arnold that Furtwangler once sent Hitler a telegram with best wishes for his birthday, although this is just malicious fabrication. Emmi Straube and Lieutenant Wills become worried about Arnold's harsh approach and his seemingly relentless persecution of the musician. They protest about his behaviour but Arnold claims that he knows that the conductor 'took sides' during the War, and was on the side of the Nazis. Presenting his evidence, Arnold waits to hear the verdict on the charges of collaboration, convinced that Furtwangler is guilty.

Production

Director
István Szabó
Producer
Yves Pasquier
Art Director
Anja Muller
Editor
Sylvie Landra
Music
(non-original) Anton Bruckner, George Gershwin, Glenn Miller, Franz Schubert and Ludwig Van Beethoven
Screenplay
Ronald Harwood, based on his own stage play
Director of Photography
Lajos Koltai

Review

An adaptation of Ronald Harwood's own stage play, and the production which led to the writer being chosen by Roman Polanski to co-write the award-winning script for The Pianist, Taking Sides in its' film version is kept by director István Szabó (Mephisto / Meeting Venus) as a tight, enclosed production, true to its' stage roots, even though the art director is Ken Adam, responsible for such spectacular sets as Dr.Strangelove's War Room and the villain's volcano base in You Only Live Twice. Harwood's script details the inconsistencies within Furtwangler's own arguments, and Harvey Keitel gives one of his most committed performances in some time as Arnold, already prejudiced with the belief that any artist who remained in Germany after the Nazis came to power in the 30s was complicit with the regime by their mere presence in the country. Its' a difficult argument, and Stellen Skarsgard (Ronin / The Exorcist - The Beginning) gives a fine performance as the increasingly battered and weary Furtwangler, never quite letting the audience decide on any particular verdict about the man and his choices. The eventual verdict was a compromise, which never the less had repercussions on the musician, and despite the feeling that neither Arnold or Furtwangler are entirely in the clear, the two lead performances and Harwood's script make this a fascinating and intelligent look at a painful piece of history as seen by the victors.