Film details

Taking Lives  2004

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

After the discovery of a brutalised corpse on a building site in the city of Montreal, Police chief Hugo Leclair realises that this is the latest in a bout of serial killings, the murderer working with vicious precision and violence against his victims, and calls in FBI Special Agent Illeana Scott, a specialist in deducing serial killer's methods and characteristics, seemingly able to deduce clues from their clothing, possessions or habitats. Arriving in the city, she realises that her attachment to the case is not appreciated. After the killer strikes again, he for the first time, leaves a witness, James Costa, an art dealer, and Illeana finds herself strangely drawn to him. Costa provides a sketch of the killer, being a talented artist himself, but returning to his gallery starts to feel that the killer is stalking him, presumably trying to kill the only witness. Agent Scott goes through cases of unsolved murders and finds clues that link them, and also deduces that the murderer impersonates his victims after killing them, adopting their identities and essentially living their lives for weeks or months before moving on. Her detective work leads her to interview Rebecca Asher, an elderly woman who reported to the Police that she had seen her son in the city, despite him having died decades before. Illeana starts to believe that, somehow, Mrs.Asher's son is the killer, his ability to adopt identities being caused by the fact that he is already 'officially' dead. James Costa is violently attacked by the man he drew as the suspect and only just escapes with his life. Knowing how valuable he is as the only witness the Police arrange for Costa to be taken out of the country but before they can organise an escort Costa is kidnapped but the Police manage to chase the vehicle his abductor is driving, finally sending it off the road. The kidnapper is killed but Costa manages to escape relatively unharmed. He and Illeana start to sleep together. The Police ask Mrs.Asher to come to the morgue to identify the body from the car crash, who they believe to be her son, but she tells them that the body is not her child. She leaves the morgue, and becomes a victim of the killer shortly afterwards. The maniac moves onto his next victim - FBI Agent Illeana Scott...

Production

Director
D. J. Caruso
Producer
Mark Canton, Bernie Goldman and David Heyman
Art Director
Serge Bureau
Editor
Anne V.Coates
Music
Philip Glass
Screenplay
Jon Bokenkamp, based on the novel by Michael Pye
Director of Photography
Amir Mokri

Review

Taking a serial killer mystery for his second feature film, after the uneven The Salton Sea, director D.J. Caruso finds himself delving into some of the established cliches of the genre, such as being set in a city (a la Se7en) where it never seems to stop raining, something certainly atypical of Montreal, and Angelina Jolie (miscast) has predictive and intuitive abilities which verge on the paranormal, so accurately can she predict killer characteristics, habitat and methods. Jon Bokenkamp's screenplay, based on the novel by Michael Pye, also plays its' tricky, red herring-tainted hand too early by making it pretty obvious who the killer is, mostly because there are so few other credible suspects and, like Ira Levin's A Kiss Before Dying, it is a mystery which works on the printed page but not on screen, the main twist relying on a visual identity. Caruso at least uses Montreal to its' best advantage, the city for once playing itself rather than standing in for some anonymous US location, and has a fine, largely French supporting cast, including Olivier Martinez (The Horseman On The Roof), Jean-Hugues Anglade (Betty Blue / Nikita) and the fierce Tcheky Karyo (Crying Freeman / GoldenEye), as well as small roles for the excellent Gina Rowlands (Gloria) and Cannes award-winner Marie-Josee Croze, but the script does not do them justice, and while Jolie is an eye-catching and capable actress, this attempt to meld her Lara Croft image to a Police psychological profiler is an idea that doesn't need an intuitive genius to know will not work.