Film details

The Phantom of the Opera  2004

Andrew Lloyd Webber's The Phantom of the Opera
Film still

Cast

Synopsis

1869 and the Paris Opera Populaire is reopened, the Viscompte Raoul De Chagny discovering that rising young star Christine Daae is to be the understudy to the opera house's prima diva, La Carlotta. He and Christine were sweethearts as children and he still hankers for her. He does not know that Christine has been trained and nurtured by The Phantom, a shadowy masked figure who is believed to dwell in the sewers beneath the Opera House. Stagehands believe he is just a myth but he exists, having been saved from a circus freak show by the theatre ballet mistress Madame Guy years before, observing the stage and the performances from his hiding places. Carlotta throws a tantrum and walks out of the theatre, allowing Christine to step into her role. Her performance is a huge success. The Phantom, captivated by her, takes her to his lair where, driven mad with curiosity, she removes The Phantom's mask, revealing his scarred, disfigured visage. Raoul and Christine meet for the first time in years and become lovers, but their relationship cripples The Phantom with jealousy and rage. The Phantom demands he is feted and recognised for his talent by the new owners of the Opera House, who refuse, and he gets his revenge leaving threatening letters and murdering a stagehand, with the promise of more mayhem to come. The Opera House throws a masked ball to which The Phantom attends, his mask making him unnoticed in the thronging crowd, but his rage at seeing Raoul and the woman he loves together grows yet further. La Carlotta returns to take the lead in a new production but The Phantom sabotages her rehearsals, then sends a huge crystal chandelier crashing into the auditorium, using the panic to abduct Christine and take her into the bowels of the theatre. Taking a pistol, Raoul goes into the tunnels beneath the Opera House, determined to confront The Phantom and save the woman he loves.

Production

Director
Joel Schumacher
Producer
Andrew Lloyd Webber
Art Director
Paul Kirby
Editor
Terry Rawlings
Music
Andrew Lloyd Webber, (lyrics) Richard Stilgoe and Charles Hart
Screenplay
Andrew Lloyd Webber and Joel Schumacher, based on the musical by Andrew Lloyd Webber, Charles Hart and Richard Stilgoe, adapted from the novel by Gaston Leroux
Director of Photography
John Mathieson

Review

Gaston Leroux's now little-read novel has led itself to all sorts of interpretations, from Lon Chaney's 1925 classic through a version in 1943 where the Phantom took second place to the warblings of Nelson Eddy and Jeanette MacDonald, an undervalued Hammer version in 1963 and a Dario Argento outing which was probably the low point of the cult director's career, but none has been so elaborately tooled, grandly staged or surprisingly bloodless, in all meanings of the word, as this Joel Schumacher-helmed version of the Andrew Lloyd Webber musical. With the stage version still running in several countries, Webber's take on the Phantom is virtually critic-proof and its' fans will point to the long runs and millions of albums sold, but the producers have taken the sheer recognition of the production as an excuse to avoid stars in the cast (both Antonio Banderas and John Travolta were mentioned for the central role who here, unlike other outings, is nameless instead of being called Erik). Casting Gerald Butler (Dracula 2001) and Emmy Rossum (Mystic River) may have knocked a few dollars off the budget but neither is strong enough to carry their roles fully, Butler being particularly anonymous. Without the mask he'd be virtually indistinguishable from any of the extras, so mild is the Phantom's 'disfigurement'. One could get a more horrific appearance by picking at a spot. Webber's version, scripted by, Lord help us, Ben Elton, has all the set-pieces of the original, but none of these are shot for impact, as if the makers knew their target audience is the women of a certain age who worshiped Michael Crawford when he took the role, so none of the shocks actually shock, or even mildly surprise. Webber's musical motifs still have power, even if repeated endlessly in variations, but it only reinforces the feeling that one is watching a collection of promo videos laced together to promote yet further album sales.