Film details
Imagining Argentina 2003
Still unavailable
Cast
-
-
-
Ruben Blades
-
Claire Bloom
-
John Wood
-
Maria Canals
-
Leticia Dolera
-
Kuno Becker
-
Anton Lesser
-
Irene Escolar
-
Fernando Tielve
-
Hector Bordoni
Synopsis
In May 1976 Argentina is in the grip of the totalitarian military government, and dissent and rebellion are ruthlessly quelled. Carlos Rueda runs a children's theatre, staging plays and running a young person's theatre group, while his wife, Cecilia, is a journalist who is investigating those who are known as The Disappeared - those who are opposed to the military junta and have protested or become involved in political resistance, and who have simply disappeared, the suspicion being they have been abducted, tortured and murdered. Their mothers, wearing white headscarves, protest silently in the La Plaza De Mayo every day in mute defiance of the government. Cecilia publishes her article, and then disappears. Carlos enquires about her through official government channels, but hears nothing. He tries to explain to their daughter Teresa what has happened to her mother, but fails. A boy belonging to his theatre troupe tells him that his father has also vanished, and Carlos suddenly develops a supernatural power which enables him to see what has happened to those who have been seized and also causes him to see the future, what will eventually happen to them. He starts to gather relatives of the missing together for meetings in his garden, and tries to explain to them what he is experiencing, but finds it emotionally shattering. He also gets brief flashes of Cecilia and her imprisonment and torture, but cannot divine anything more. The junta increases the number of arrests and seizures, and Carlos starts to realise that he too is being followed, his house being put under surveillance. Driving into the desert pampas he gets more images of Cecilia being tortured and raped, but cannot ascertain her whereabouts, only knowing it must be somewhere in the area. More and more relatives of the disappeared come to Carlos' meetings, each hoping for news of a missing relative or loved one, but during one of the sessions he realises that one of the attendees, Gustavo Santos, is a government plant, spying on the meetings and those attending. Gustavo has Teresa arrested and imprisoned with Cecilia, the police then closing down Carlos' theatre. Teresa is with a group of children who are taken away from the other prisoners and executed, along with Silvio Ayala, a former colleague of Carlos. Knowing that she will be among the next group of prisoners to 'disappear' permanently, Cecilia tries to escape. International pressure is being exerted on the Argentinian government but they deny any wrongdoing in the field of human rights, but are trying to speed up their rate of executions, trying to eliminate all possible witnesses....
Production
- Director
- Christopher Hampton
- Producer
- Geoffrey Lands, Michael Peyser, Diane Sillian and Santiago Pozo
- Art Director
- Alejandro Fernandez and Coca Oderigo
- Editor
- George Akers
- Music
- George Fenton
- Screenplay
- Christopher Hampton, based on the original novel by Lawrence Thornton
- Director of Photography
- Guillermo Navarro
Review
Genuinely laughed off the screen at the Berlin Film Festival, and the recipient of some truly damning reviews, all the more surprising considering the talent on both sides of the camera, Imagining Argentina takes a difficult subject, adapted from a well regarded novel, and destroys it with the approach taken. Christopher Hampton is well regarded for his screenplays such as Dangerous Liaisons and Carrington, both adapted from other source material, but a director he clearly isn't, having turned his adaptation of Joseph Conrad's The Secret Agent into an inept farrago and with this film his decision to adapt Antonio Banderas' character's visions into a form of South American 'magic realism', beyond anything imagined by Borges or Castanada merely makes them incongruous. If the script sledgehammers its' parallels, doves flying to represent freedom, angelic hymns on the soundtrack every time children appear to indicate innocence, then the scenes of torture and rape are made very less powerful by the use of soft photography and children's choirs, delving into a form of kitsch bad taste. Interestingly no one ever questions the validity of Carlos' 'visions', accepting them as genuine immediately and giving his meetings the atmosphere of a South American Doris Stokes seance. Banderas looks the part, even if most of the time he is sobbing or contorted with pain, while Emma Thompson's eventual change into a semi-action heroine comes at a point in the movie where the audience is probably prepared to accept anything. The most effective scenes are of the silent mothers keeping their vigil, and Hampton uses some of the genuine mothers as part of the crowd, but this film does nothing for the memory of those they lost.