Film details
His Brother 2003
Son Frère
Still unavailable
Cast
-
Bruno Todeschini
-
Eric Cararaca
-
Nathalie Boutefeu
-
Maurice Garrel
-
Antoinette Moya
-
Sylvain Jacques
-
Fred Ulysse
-
Robinson Stevenin
-
Claudine Benichon
-
Veronique Lafrate
-
Cathy Rondant
-
Sabrina Fessan
Synopsis
In a small town on the Brittany coast in a warm July two young men, brothers Thomas and Luc, sit on a bench, staring out to sea, listening to an old man, one of the town's inhabitants, tell of how years before the old man's nephew had drowned off this stretch of shore. The brothers were virtually estranged until six months previously. Thomas, thirty two, and two years older than his brother who livies in Paris, calls Luc impulsively, having not spoken for years, and tells him that he is suffering from a serious, potentially fatal blood disease. Luc agrees to accompany Thomas to a consultation at a Parisian hospital, but the diagnosis is worse than first expected, and Thomas is admitted. Luc contacts their parents, and Thomas' girlfriend Claire, and they arrive to be at Thomas' bedside. Thomas' illness remains serious, and the two brothers are reunited, putting their enmity, which neither will discuss, behind them, Luc visiting his brother every day, but his illness is having effects outside of the the family. Thomas' relationship with Claire deteriorates and Luc finds that he is also becomes distant from his lover Vincent, losing all interest in making love with him, instead only seeing in his body the damage and ruin illness can bring. Thomas is released from hospital but is still very ill. Claire tells him that she is ending with him and prepares to move out of the house they share, Luc leaving Vincent and moving in to take her place and tend to his brother. They meet for the final time as Claire is leaving, and she and Luc embrace, Claire kissing him, trying to put into words and gestures the love she feels for him and his brother. Moved and unable to articulate what he is feeling he makes a major confession to Claire, something he has told no one else - that his first sexual experience was an innocent but incestuous one with Thomas. Thomas' condition gets yet worse and he is taken back into hospital for an emergency operation, to remove his spleen as a last attempt at saving his life. As Thomas is prepared for surgery by two orderlies, who shave his body hair and ready him for the operation, their father tells Luc that he wishes it were he, Luc, who were ill, and not Thomas, comments which cause Luc to refuse to talk to his father. The operation proves to be of no benefit to Thomas. Discharging himself he travels with Luc and his mother to their holiday home in Brittany. Through July and August Thomas seems to rally, and the brothers become truly close for the first time in years, but after a severe haemorrhage, from which Thomas recovers, he decides that to live like this is no life at all....
Production
- Director
- Patrice Chéreau
- Producer
- Pierre Chevalier
- Editor
- François Gedigier
- Screenplay
- Patrice Chéreau and Anna-Louise Trividie, based on the novel by Philippe Besson
- Director of Photography
- Eric Gautier
Review
Patrice Chérnau's most notable film was the opulent and high budget La Reine Margot in 1994, and since that lavish historical epic his films have paradoxically become smaller, from Those Who Love Me Can Take The Train to the barren and bleak Intimacy, and with Son Frére Chéreau has even cut back on the emotional tangles of Intimacy, the rift between the brothers never being explained, with obviously long-standing feuds within the family remaining hidden. Intimacy is something which is slowly drained from both brother's relationships, as Thomas' long-standing girlfriend leaves him and Luc finds himself realising he no longer wants his lover, but a bond between the siblings grows. The main emotion stirred by the film is pity, with everyone slowly becoming isolated, sons from parents, lovers from partners, and the scene of Thomas undergoing preparation for surgery, being shaved until his weak body looks helpless and vulnerable is genuinely painful and upsetting to see. Winning the Silver Bear at the 2003 Berlin Film Festival, Chérnau's film will strike some as tender and rational and others as stark and emotionally cold, but it has to be admitted that the director can show the mechanics of relationships, particularly those which have a damaging effect on those involved.