Film details

The Butterfly Effect  2003

Film still

Cast

  • Ashton Kutcher
  • Amy Smart
  • Eric Stoltz
  • Melora Walters
  • Elden Henson
  • Kevin Schmidt
  • William Lee Scott
  • Brandy Hendrick
  • Kevan Ohtsji
  • John Patrick Amedori
  • Irene Gorovala

Synopsis

A young boy, Evan Treborn, suffers from blackouts, leaving him with memory losses during which he can remember nothing of what has happened. He is encouraged to keep a diary by Dr.Redfield, the neuro-specialist in charge of his case. Invited over to the house of his friends, brother and sister Tommy and Kayleigh Miller, during summer vacation, Evan finds their father, George has bought a video camera and, in the basement of the house, is forced to make a child porn video, once again his mind blanking out the terrible details. Evan finally persuades his mother Andrea to let him visit his 'sick' father in hospital. The 'hospital' is an asylum and his father is a dangerous mental patient, attacking Evan when he sees him in a private room, his father being killed by a blow from one of the guards trying to save Evan from being strangled. After a prank with a large firework suggested by the increasingly sadistic Tommy goes horribly wrong, he, Kayleigh and their friend Lenny follow Tommy into the woods, where they find him about to set fire to Evan's dog. Something violent happens but once more Evan blacks out. He and his mother move out of the area shortly afterwards, Evan promising Kayleigh he will come back for her one day and warning her about her increasingly unstable brother. Seven years later Evan is studying at college but is compelled to go back to his home town, and finds that Larry is now a withdrawn hermit, making model planes, forever changed by whatever happened back in the woods. Evan also finds that Kayleigh is working as a waitress in a run-down diner, her dreams of going to college dispelled and finding herself hurt and betrayed, reminding Evan that he promised to come back for her, to save her from her abusive father. She stalks away angrily, and the next morning Evan gets a violent phone call from an abusive Tommy, telling him that after he met Kayleigh she went home and killed herself, seeing him again being the final straw in her ruined life. Evan is stunned and starts to re-read the journals he kept and finds that by reading them he can transport himself back to those times. He finds that the stunt with the firework killed a mother and her young child, and, now a young boy again, goes to Kayleigh's fathers' house, threatening him with exposure of his abuse and telling Kayleigh to be stronger against him. This affects the future so that both he and Kayleigh are at college, and are boyfriend and girlfriend, but Tommy has grown into a very violent and dangerous young man, wrecking Evan's car on prom night. Evan in turn attacks him and, in his rage, kills Tommy. Evan is sent to prison, and soon finds himself the object of harassment and violence and realises the only way he can get out is to read his journals, but these are taken from him by members of the Aryan Brotherhood faction who make it clear they want Evan to be their sex slave. Helped by one of the other inmates Evan manages to stab one of the Aryans and get his diaries back, sending himself to another time once more, but each time he does, trying to improve the situation he or someone else is in, it results in disaster, with himself, Kayleigh or someone close to him being put into a threatening or fatal situation, his past changing each time he time-jumps, and never for the better. Evan knows he has to change things once and for all, and tries to make sure that nothing of what transpired from his young days ever happens...

Production

Director
Eric Bress and J. Mackye Gruber
Producer
Chris Bander, A.J. Rix, Anthony Rhulen, Lisa Richardson and J.C.Spink
Art Director
Shannon Grover and Jeremy Stanbridge
Editor
Peter Amundsen
Music
Michael Suby
Screenplay
Eric Bress and J. Mackye Gruber
Director of Photography
Matthew F. Leonetti

Review

From the writers of Final Destination 2, with which it shares a certain knottiness and circularity in the screenplay, The Butterfly Effect takes its' title from a tenet of chaos theory, that the flapping of a butterfly's wings in one part of the world can cause a tidal wave on the other side of the globe. This is a truly clever and ingenious screenplay, with every alteration Evan makes in the fabric of time causing new and untold disasters and horrors (incarceration in an asylum / the loss of both arms / terminal cancer / disfiguring drug addiction / a life of prostitution / becoming a Born-Again Christian, to name but a few) for the various characters, but it perhaps takes just a couple of steps too far, piling ghastly misjudgment upon disaster, until the only way is to stop the 'beginning' ever occurring, which the script does very well. Although good in the role it is Ashton Kutcher who is one of the weakest characters, a reactive Everyman having to cope with the mayhem he is causing, although he is surrounded by fine performances from Eric Stoltz, a small but effective role as Kayleigh's abusive father, Elden Henson (a Phillip Seymour Hoffman lookalike) as Lenny, who undergoes some of the most dramatic plot twists, and above all Amy Smart as Kayleigh, whose life changes horribly and very convincingly, with the actress giving fine portrayals in all her different character facets. In some aspects this is a very cruel and relentless film, the character of Tommy, at his different ages, being one of the most scary and deranged villains in quite some time and the prison sequence, although overlong, has the same bubbling air of claustrophobia and sexual violence as the cable series Oz. Extremely complex but made with care and a touch of style, The Butterfly Effect is remarkably ambitious, but the scale of what it is attempting eventually holds it back, although it has to be praised for its' often bleak scenario and a perfectly, judged bitter-sweet finish.