Film details

Criminal  2004

Film still

Cast

  • John C.Reilly
  • Maggie Gyllenhaal
  • Diego Luna
  • Peter Mullan
  • Jonathan Tucker
  • Enrico Colantoni
  • Zitto Kazann
  • Michael Shannon
  • Brandon Keener
  • Maeve Quinlan
  • Soledad St.Hilaire
  • Brent Sexton

Synopsis

Section Eight, the company formed under the business partnership of Steven Soderberg and George Clooney, has produced in some interesting movies in the last couple of years, including the vastly underrated Solaris and the entertaining Welcome To Collingwood, and their latest production is an English language version of the clever and involving con-movie Nine Queens, one of the biggest international hits to emerge from Argentina in the last decade or so. Dependable character John C.Reilly (who got great notices for his role in Chicago) plays Richard Gaddes, a con man who sees a young man, Rodrigo (Diego Luna - Dirty Dancing II: Havana Nights), pull a daring banknote scam in a bank one day. Following him he saves him from arrest in another bank when he pulls the same trick, by claiming to be a plain-clothes policeman. He offers him a partnership, seeing the young man's potential talent for the con, and soon the two are involved in a scheme to pull a stunt involving the sale of a rare and hugely valuable set of stamps, known as the Nine Queens. Their attempts to sell the stamps, and the sudden changes in their fortunes when the trick goes disastrously wrong draws in other people, including Richard's sister Valerie (indie favourite Maggie Gyllenhaal - Secretary) and their young brother Michael (Jonathan Tucker). Of course as anyone who has seen a David Mamet movie will know, there are crosses and counter-crosses afoot but, unlike some of the Mamet imitators which have appeared recently, these are clever and genuinely unexpected, and although this probably won't be quite as good as the original, which was a genuine delight, this has a good chance of being a high quality, considered remake.

Production

Director
Gregory Jacobs
Producer
Gregory Jacobs, George Clooney and Steven Soderberg
Art Director
Philip Messina
Editor
Stephan Mirrione
Music
Alex Wurman
Screenplay
Gregory Jacobs and Steven Soderberg, based on an original screenplay by Fabien Bielinsky and the subsequent film Neuve Reinen
Director of Photography
Chris Menges

Review

A relocation of the award winning Nine Queens from its' native Argentina to California, Criminal is as efficient, well planned and quietly admirable as some of the scams carried out by the experienced Richard (the ever excellent John C. Reilly - Chicago) and Rodrigo (Diego Luna - Goal), even though for a character who is supposed to be a successful con-artist Richard does seems to have more than his fair share of failures and misfortunes, something not shared by his counterpart Ricardo Darin in the original film. Unfortunately the shift in situation alters the story in ways the filmmakers had perhaps not anticipated. Nueve Reinen pitted its' protagonists against a country on the verge of economic meltdown where even the banks were unwilling to let the smallest investors withdraw their money, the two conmen almost fighting for survival by any means they knew how. Shifting the story to the USA brings unwelcome comparisons with the works of David Mamet and therefore the audience may suspect, and rightly so, that no one can be trusted, doublecrosses are in the offing, and even the most inconsequential act is somehow linked to the bigger, bolder scam. Even the original item of the con, which gave the Argentinian production it's title, a sheet of nine stamps bearing a Queen's head, has been changed to a US Treasury bond, as if an audience wouldn't accept the intrinsic vale of just a partial sheet of mere stamps. Director Gregory Jacobs has made a perfectly serviceable US remake of an intricate and engaging film, with a cast, although under-utilising the excellent Maggie Gyllenhall, that fill their roles perfectly. But unfortunately in taking it away from its' original setting one can see the mechanics that make it all work all too clearly.