Film details

Merci Docteur Rey  2002

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Thomas Beaumont is a young gay man living in Paris, but has to hide his orientation from his overbearing and obtrusive mother, the famed opera singer Elizabeth, with whom he still lives. Having placed a personal ad in order to try something adventurous and unusual, Thomas receives a reply from an older man who has an idea - that Thomas should come to his apartment and watch him from his closet. The idea appeals to Thomas and he is watching from the closet when he sees a young man enter the apartment. Thomas thinks he may be a rent boy but is stunned when the young man murders his older host. More shocks come when Thomas discovers that the older man was his father, Bob, whom his mother had told him died when he was a baby. Bob in fact left her for another man. Thomas is in turmoil and tries to visit the nearest psychiatrist, Doctor Rey, but once he gets to her office he finds that the Doctor has had a heart attack, so finds himself opening up to Penelope, one of her patients. Penelope is being treated by the doctor for an identity problem. Having taken up voiceover and dubbing work and having abandoned her stage career, she has become known as the voice of Vanessa Redgrave in French movies, and now believes that she actually is the actress. Being pressured by his mother to bring his girlfriend to one of her performances, Elizabeth still believing that Thomas has a girlfriend, he manages to persuade Penelope to accompany him, but once there they find that Vanessa Redgrave is also at the opera house, and Penelope finds herself snubbed by both the actress and Robert's disapproving mother. Determined to find his father's murderer, Thomas almost by accident meets the young man who slew Bob, and he tells him that he was indeed Bob's lover and was in a state of heartbreak after Bob cruelly ended their relationship. He was heartbroken, and happened to meet Elizabeth. Discovering how Bob had betrayed this young man, and realising that he felt as hurt as she did years before by Bob's departure, she paid him to murder Bob, a shared revenge. Elizabeth and Thomas are reconciled, both realising that they have both shared something deep and profound, but there is room in Thomas' life for both the killer and Penelope, whose encounter with the aloof and unpleasant star she had adored has changed her for the good....

Production

Director
Andrew Litvack
Producer
Rahila Boolwala and Nathalie Gastaldo
Art Director
Jacques Bufnoir
Editor
Giles Gardner
Music
Geoff Alexander
Screenplay
Andrew Litvach
Director of Photography
Laurent Machuel

Review

Co-produced by Merchant-Ivory Productions, and released by the company itself rather than going through another distributor, Merci Docteur Rey features a few familiar MI faces in cameo roles but tries to be a black comedy, a light-hearted murder mystery and a story of strained mother-son relationships, none of which convinces. The three stories seem to be linked by a loose series of coincidences, and the Jane Birkin character being the French dubbing voice for Vanessa Redgrave for most of her career (a not uncommon occurrence in Europe where various voice artists always cover the same actors) just seems to be an excuse to get the real actress into the film for a few scenes, from which it must be said she does not emerge well. Director Andrew Litvack's screenplay is often quite obviously a series of in-jokes from which the audience are excluded, something the appearances of such Merchant-Ivory regulars such as Redgrave and Simon Callow does nothing to assuage. Litvack is obviously trying for an updated, polysexual spin on the classic French farce, but his characters are all either utterly self-obsessed or, in the case of Penelope, utterly self-divorced, living their lives vicariously through other personas, and while such stagers as Jane Birkin and Dianne Weist are at least game performers, male lead Stanislas Nerhar's performance is occasionally wooden despite having to spiral through emotions ranging from shock to mania. Merchant Ivory's period films may have their detractors but at least they know what they are about, something this hybrid offering doesn't.