Film details
Song for a Raggy Boy 2003
Still unavailable
Cast
-
-
Iain Glen
-
Simone Bendix
-
Marc Warren
-
Dudley Sutton
-
Claus Bue
-
Alan Devlin
-
Stuart Graham
-
John Travers
-
Chris Newman
-
Andrew Simpson
-
Mark Butler
Synopsis
Lay teacher William Franklin is assigned to a post at St.Jude's Reformatory School in Ireland in 1939, arriving at the same time as Patrick Delaney, a thirteen year old who has also been sent there. Franklin's subject is English and he plans to introduce the largely illiterate boys to poetry as well as teaching them grammar and composition. Once at the school he is alarmed to find that the boys are known by numbers instead of names, and the school is run under a regime of callous brutality, one particularly sadistic member of staff being Brother John, and he crosses swords with Franklin when the teacher steps in to stop the brother strapping Patrick Delaney, now known as 743, across the face. As an act of reprisal Brother John punishes all the boys, telling them that Delaney is to blame for their strapping. Franklin continues with his classes where one of the brightest pupils, 636, otherwise known as Liam Mercier, borrows books on the Spanish Civil War from him, and deduces from what he has read and been told that Franklin fought in the conflict on the side of the Communists, and saw his wife and best friend executed by Franco's soldiers. Father Damien, the school's principle, is badgered by Brother John to sack Franklin, but he refuses. Meanwhile Delaney has fallen into the clutches of Brother Mac, a predator who molests him, punishing him afterwards for daring to mention what has happened while at confession. As Christmas approaches the boys make a crib for the Christmas Nativity scene and Franklin, defying Brother John's instructions, takes the boys through the town square to see the Christmas decorations. On Christmas morning brothers Gerald Peters (458) and Sean Peters (568) go to their respective sides of the fence which separates the younger and older boys and exchange a hug, the first time they have seen each other for nearly a year, but are seen by Brother John, who shaves their heads and fiercesomely straps them both. Liam Mercier goes to Franklin for him to stop the beatings but Brother John demands that Brother Mac insists that nothing has happened, or he will expose his sexual tamperings with the boys. Brother John realises that Liam Mercier knows about Franklin's past and demands he tells him what he knows, but Liam refuses, Brother John repeatedly beating him in front of Brother Mac when he will not talk, the priest only stopping when he realises the boy is dead. Brothers John and Mac are dismissed from the school and given other posts within the church and Franklin prepares to leave, until a meeting with Patrick Delaney makes him change his mind and stay. End captions reveal what eventually happened to the major characters.
Production
- Director
- Aisling Walsh
- Producer
- Tristan Orpen Lynch, Dominic Wright, John McDonnell and Kevin Byron Murphy
- Art Director
- Owen Power
- Editor
- Bryan Oates
- Music
- Richard Blackford
- Screenplay
- Patrick Galvin, Aisling Walsh and Kevin Byron Murphy, based on the novel by Patrick Galvin
- Director of Photography
- Peter Robinson
Review
Despite having some impressive names in the cast, including Aidan Quinn (Avalon, whose career has taken a few stutters in recent years), the ceaselessly working Iain Glen (Darkness / Spy Sorge) and the veteran Dudley Sutton, this essentially can only come across as a gender-changed version of Peter Mullen's impassioned The Magdelene Sisters, but done far more crudely, and subsequently far less well, the other Brothers with which Franklin has to deal essentially being little more than the Gestapo with rosaries, with broad and pantomime villain performances to match. Director Aisling Walsh has a good cast but apparently does not know how to use them, Iain Glen's Brother John is particularly shallow and Marc Warren's Brother Mac is also a thin character, able to be manipulated at the merest threat of exposure when in actuality he would have to be as cunning and mendacious as any of the other Brothers with a secret. Certain details, taken from Patrick Galvin's memoir are far more effective for being small but telling, such as the fact that the boys were only known by numbers, and that even siblings were segregated by a fence, separating younger and older boys, a frightening use of divide and conquer, allowing the church brothers free rein over the younger ones, but some of the overemphatic direction and dwellings on wounds and wheals would be more suited to a horror movie rather than a supposedly committed drama. As with their female equivalents the Irish Church schools system existed until the end of the Eighties, and most of the paperwork, documents and records have conveniently been lost or destroyed in fires, which statistically make Irish church schools the worst fire insurance risks in the entire solar system, but while the system and those who controlled it and covered up it's excesses need to be exposed, Walsh's film is not the vehicle with which to do it.