Film details

Tristan + Isolde  2004

Tristan and Isolde
Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Britain in the Dark Ages, the tribes, having been abandoned by the collapse of the Roman Empire, have been subsumed by Irish warriors led by the sadistic King Donnchadh. Tristan, the son of an English warlord, is orphaned when his parents are killed by the Irish mercenaries and is only saved by Lord Marke, a Cornish warlord, who rescues the boy but loses his hand as he does so. Marke takes the boy back to Cornwall and raises him as his own. A decade passes and Isolde, the daughter of King Donnchadh, is to be married to her father's finest soldier and the Irish extort riches from the English townships as a wedding gift, but Tristan, now grown, plans an ambush of the Irish convoy. Many of Donnchadh's troops are killed, including Isolde's intended, slain by Tristan himself, who is wounded by a poisoned sword and seems to die. Given a hero's funeral and sent out to sea on a pyre boat, Isolde finds his comatose body and restores him to health with potions she distills from plants and herbs. The two fall for each other, but Isolde does not reveal her real identity or her links to the Irish throne. Donnchadh offers his daughter's hand to the winner of a tournament, planning to fix the contest so that Lord Wictred, an English traitor, will win, but Tristan enters, fighting for Lord Marke's lands, and wins the contest. The rules mean that she is to marry Lord Marke, which she agrees to do, telling Tristan that it will bring peace between England and Ireland. They marry and the English tribes agree to unite under Marke, but the attraction between Tristan and Isolde is still strong, and they continue to meet illicitly. Lord Wictred discovers their relationship and tells Donnchadh he has knowledge which will deliver the control of England to him. Joining with Melot, the aggrieved nephew of Marke, Wictred plans to reveal Isolde's adultery at Marke's coronation, but does not realise how deep Tristan's love for Isolde runs.

Production

Director
Kevin Reynolds
Producer
Moshe Diamant, Lisa Ellzcy, Giannina Facio and Elie Samaha
Art Director
Johnny Byrne, David Wilson and Jan Svoboda
Editor
Peter Boyle
Music
Anne Dudley
Screenplay
Dean Georgaris
Director of Photography
Arthur Reinhart

Review

The use of the '+' symbol instead of the rather more straightforward 'And' brings echoes of Baz Luhmann's William Shakespeare's Romeo + Juliet, as if hinting to potential audiences the basic template of the romance, a ploy also used by 2005's Love + Hate, another reworking of the Shakespeare tale. An ancient epic folk tale, probably best known as the basis of the opera by Richard Wagner, director Kevin Reynolds is certainly striving for some form of authenticity in period look if not the actual story, with almost everyone bar Sophia Myles' Isolde being dressed in various grimy shades of grot, Isolde wearing pastels and what appear to primitively dyed rough materials, and while the Irish Film Board may be boasting the number of actual Irish locations used, they come over as so overcast, grey and uninviting as work in exactly the opposite way than the tourist board would want. Reynolds has visited this sort of territory before with his record-breaking Robin Hood - Prince Of Thieves, but his treatment here is rather more serious and the love story between the two title characters rather more tragic, one sensing that this pair will not make the happy ever after phase of the story, even if the script by Dean Georgaris tends to telegraph the point with mordant and gloomy predictions for the pair by virtually all concerned. And while one isn't looking for totally accurate period detail, the fact that the couple sread lines from John Donne's poem The Good Morrow to each other, a piece written some four hundred years after the events of the movie, seems to be taking artistic license a touch too far. James Franco (Spider-Man) manages a fairly convincing accent, certainly better then Kevin Costner managed under Reynolds' direction, while Myles (Thunderbirds) is winsome as the protected heroine. Rufus Sewell, usually the villain in historical pieces such as A Knight's Tale, is suitably brave and sympathetic as Lord Marke, reluctantly becoming the husband of Isolde even though he knows he has no real place in her heart. A rather more brutal and grime-encrusted take on the two star-crossed lovers of The Bard, but sincerely made with a strong visual eye, even if the downbeat ending may not be to everyone's satisfaction.