Film details
Yes 2004
Still unavailable
Cast
-
-
Simon Abkarian
-
-
Samantha Bond
-
Shirley Henderson
-
Shiela Hancock
-
Stephanie Leonidas
-
Gary Lewis
-
-
Raymond Waring
-
Barbara Oxley
-
Lol Coxhill
Synopsis
'She' is a woman in her early forties, living in London, where she was born but having been raised in the US. A scientist, She is married to Anthony, a politician who is repeatedly unfaithful, and the relationship between the pair has almost irrevocably broken down. Their cleaner knows many of their secrets, and relates them directly to the audience. After an official function, where the couple openly row, She meets a handsome Lebanese chef, 'He', who tells her that in the Lebanon he was a respected surgeon. They flirt and arrange a liaison for a forthcoming afternoon, which ends with the two in bed. Their affair becomes more and more torrid but She and He find great divisions between their respective cultures which, combined with the effort of keeping their meetings secret, puts a strain on both of them. He loses his job after reacting to pointedly racist comments from a colleague, Whizzer, while Anthony makes a lame pass at Grace, his god-daughter, causing She to erupt furiously and demand they finally divorce. Having lost his job, He starts to feel alienated and disillusioned with the West and wants to return to his homeland. He returns to Beirut. Having heard her Irish aunt is dying, the woman who raised her as a child, She takes a trip to Belfast and reaches the dying woman on her death bed. With her dying breath the aunt, a fervent Communist in her youth, urges She to go to Cuba. She decides to take the trip. Calling Him in Beirut she offers Him a plane ticket to Havana to meet her. He declines the offer. She travels to Havana and realises that She has made the right choice, but what is She to do about the other major decisions to be made in her life?
Production
- Director
- Sally Potter
- Producer
- Christopher Sheppard and Andrew Fierberg
- Art Director
- Claire Spooner
- Editor
- Daniel Goddard
- Music
- Sally Potter and Fred Frith
- Screenplay
- Sally Potter
- Director of Photography
- Alexei Rodionov
Review
Having tried, and failed, to cross the divide between arthouse (such as her hit Orlando) and mainstream with the ambitious but deeply flawed The Man Who Cried, a box-office flop despite the casting of Johnny Depp and Christina Ricci, writer and director Sally Potter eschews commercial possibilities for a dedicated arthouse production, made all the more audience-alienating by not giving the main characters actual names, instead referring to them as She and He, and having the entire film delivered in verse, the norm for many Shakespeare adaptations but unusual for a modern-day tale of adultery and betrayal. It is a very ambitious move, but perhaps such ambition is applied to the wrong project, as the dialogue seems strained in such otherwise naturalistic settings, with some of the forced rhymes occasionally coming as artificial and contrived, especially when the script tries to link the scientist's career and theories into the dialogue, adding meditations o the structure of cells into rhetorical questions about her marriage and affair. Similarly the florid lines seem out of place when used in His workplace, a frantic kitchen where, as seems to be compulsory, there is also a heavy peppering of strong language, again seeming out of place. Potter still reveals that the one thing she does not possess in her artistic portfolio is a sense of humour, and there are scenes which just beg for a touch of levity to lighten the solemnity and false gravitas of the situation and everyone involved in it. Later plot twists such as Her sudden flight to Havana and decision to make contact with Him again also seem as if they are constructs just to change the location and to give the character a blameless exit from both her marriage and her responsibilities, and the film ends on an ambiguous note. Joan Allen, Sam Neill and Simon Abkarian all give committed performances, even when having to tackle some of the more convoluted and complexly structured stretches of the scripts. but Potter's dedication to making her film so distinctive and self-consciously 'arty' makes it inaccessible even for her fans.