Film details

We Don't Live Here Anymore  2004

Film still

Cast

  • Naomi Watts
  • Mark Ruffalo
  • Peter Krause
  • Sam Charles
  • Halli Page
  • Jennifer Bishop
  • Jim Francis
  • Jennifer Mawhinney
  • Amber Rothwell
  • Meg Roe
  • Marc Baur

Synopsis

They say when you're hot you should make the most of it, and the excellent Naomi Watts certainly has, following her highly praised performance in 21 Grams with a string of films yet to come, including I Heart Huckerbees, Stay (opposite Ewan McGregor), The Assassination Of Richard Nixon and The Ring 2 all to get finished before moving onto Peter Jackson's King Kong in 2005!. She even turns co-producer for this adaptation of two short stories by Andre Dubus (In The Bedroom), namely Adultery and We Don't Live Here Anymore. Set on a university campus, the main characters are two male teachers, Jack (Mark Ruffalo) and his wife Terry (Laura Dern), and Hank (Peter Krause) and his wife Edith (Watts). The two couples are good friends, but Jack and Edith share a mutual attraction which they are both about to act upon, even though Jack is already feeling guilty about the effect it could have on Terry. Jack regardless beds Edith, thinking he'll get away with it, but Edith is already strangely predisposed to their eventual discovery. After a party celebrating the accepting of a poem of Hanks' by The New Yorker magazine, Terry is persuaded by Jack to tell him how Hank made a pass at her and kissed her while drunk. This causes a clash of feelings within Jack, who is now having a full-blown affair with Edith, both using the idea of his wife having an affair as an excuse for his own infidelity but also being shocked that she could possibly betray him. Jack and Terry's relationship starts to break down, Terry turning to drink and eventually beginning an affair with Hank, and her admission to her husband of what is happening doesn't get the reaction she expects. Directed by John Curran (Praise) the film revolves around the feelings of guilt in an affair, both the feelings an adulterer experiences as well as the emotions they think they should reveal, and Jack's self-justifications which are perfectly acceptable to him, trying to adapt circumstances into making him less culpable for what is happening in his life and his marriage. Performances, especially from the increasingly ubiquitous Watts and Ruffalo have been singled out for special praise and Curran's direction keeps the viewer involved, even if their characters are self-absorbed and seemingly cruelly unfeeling.

Production

Director
John Curran
Producer
Harvey Khan, Naomi Watts and Jonas Goodman
Art Director
Rick Willoughby
Editor
Alexandre De Franceschi
Music
Lesley Barber
Screenplay
Larry Gross, based on the short stories Adultery and We Don't Live Here Anymore by Andre Dubus
Director of Photography
Maryse Alberti

Review

Bringing together two short pieces of work by author Andre Dubus, We Don't Live Here Anymore, named after one of the Dubus stories, certainly has talent in the actors playing the four main roles, two couples who become increasingly entangled with each other's lives, resulting in the inevitable infidelities, betrayals and painful revelations, but they remain oddly unlikeable, and their actions become increasingly illogical, resulting in an effecient drama but one without the resonance of a film such as Ang Lee's The Ice Storm, which covered much of the same ground of partner-swapping, sanctioned and otherwise, in suburbia. Director John Curran has cast his film well, with Mark Ruffalo (Just Like Heaven) and Laura Dern (Jurassic Park) as Jack and Terry Linden, and Naomi Watts (King Kong / 21 Grams) and Peter Krause (TV's Six Feet Under) as friends and neighbours Hank and Edith Evans (an unfortunate name, that), but Ruffalo's Hank is soon revealed to be an unpleasant fantasist, boasting about his affairs and urging his friend to have one, perhaps to assuage the guilt that he is already seeing Edith behind Hank's back. Worse, the characters have a tendency to talk in speeches rather than dialogue, making one think that scripter Larry Gross has lifted large chunks straight out of the stories, but there is also a slanting to the characters which seems distinctly unfair. Dern's Terry is seen as a drudge, constantly having to do the chores or take care of the children, while Watts' Edith is a much freer spirit, almost giving Jack an excuse to pursue her to get away from his downtrodden wife. For all the confiding between both the men and the women, raising suspicions that their relative spouses are playing away, there is little actual development, until a climax which seems distinctly unfair with perhaps the only character who hasn't been brazenly manipulative coming off worst. The performances are strong, and the source material probably equally so, but the way they are portrayed on screen doesn't allow the audience to feel for them.