Film details

Cinderella Man  2005

Film still

Cast

  • Renne Zellweger
  • Paul Giamatti
  • Craig Bierko
  • Paddy Considine
  • Bruce McGill
  • Ron Canada
  • David Huband
  • Connor Price
  • Ariel Walker
  • Patrick Louis
  • Nicholas Campbell

Synopsis

1928, New York, and James J. Braddock is one of the hottest things in boxing, winning fight after fight. A family man, he is deeply in love with his wife, Mae, who refuses to attend his bouts, and his three young children, Jay, Rosemarie and Howard, Mae and the kids staying in their comfortable and spacious home when he fights. Five years later and America is in the grip of the Depression, and the Braddocks have been hit badly, forced out of their home into a rundown, one bedroom tenement slum. His injured right hand has made it difficult to get bouts, despite his past fame, and he relies on daily labour jobs at the docks. Managing to get another fight, and being soundly beaten, Braddock's fight licence is revoked by the board of control, despite the pleading of Joe Gould, his manager. Meeting Mike Wilson, a previously wealthy stockbroker wiped out in the crash, he and Braddock become friends. With Braddock unable to pay for heating the apartment, and meals becoming smaller and smaller, his young son becomes ill, Braddock being unable to pay for a doctor. Against his wishes Mae sends the children out to the country to stay with her relatives. He signs on the welfare roll, something he swore he would never do, and is forced to swallow his pride and ask the boxing commission for money. Joe Gould manages to secure him one final fight against a hotly-tipped heavyweight contender who wants a 'patsy', a pushover, for a bout. Braddock, to everyone's astonishment, wins the fight, causing fight promoter Jimmy Johnston, after some persuasion by Joe Gould, to give Braddock another fight to keep him on the circuit. Braddock starts to be put in the ring against highly-rated and powerful fighters, managing to beat them all until he is brought into a World Championship bout against the feared Max Baer, a fighter who has killed two men in the ring with his relentless, fearsome punching. Braddock hears that his friend Mike, living in Hooverville, a shanty town for the truly destitute, has been killed in a violent riot there. Braddock starts to become a hero among those suffering the worst in the Depression, and is dubbed 'Cinderella Man' by the writer Damon Runyon when he hears of his fall from fame and subsequent return. Knowing Baer's reputation Mae tries to stop her husband taking the fight but, knowing what it means for the ordinary people as well as his family, he is willing to give it everything he has...

Production

Director
Ron Howard
Producer
Brian Glazer, Ron Howard and Penny Marshall
Art Director
Peter Grundy and Dan Yahri
Editor
Daniel P.Hanley and Mike Hill
Music
Thomas Newman
Screenplay
Akiva Goldman and Cliff Hollingsworth, from a story by Cliff Hollingsworth
Director of Photography
Salvatore Totino

Review

The previous Ron Howard / Russell Crowe collaboration A Beautiful Mind, was certainly targeted to hit all the emotional buttons, a tortured genius, his loving wife, his overriding obsession, his eventually victory, all the sort of things Oscar-voting Academy members love. The fact that certain events were air-brushed out of the story, such as John Nash's bisexuality, his arrests for gay sex in public conveniences, the fact his wife was not exactly as supportive as the story suggested, was quietly ignored under the weight of awards and plaudits. One is tempted to think a little of the same remodelling has been done with Cinderella Man, the peerless writer Damon Runyon's term for James Braddock as he once more rose through the ranks to get a crack at the world title. Braddock's story is a true and inspiring one, but Russell Crowe makes him into a saint incarnate, just wanting to put food on the family's table, despite the fact that his stock-in-trade is to repeatedly hit another man very hard, until they don't wanna be hit no more. The family is clearly destitute, but its' a strangely clean and sanitised Depression, in which everyone is oddly dignified, and one just has to ask where the money and nice, spacious house went in the five years which then sees the Braddocks in penury. The film only really comes to life in the boxing scenes, where Crowe certainly looks the part as a determined, rampaging fighter (and you can insert your own joke here) and Howard really manages to get the real feel and atmosphere of the ring and also the desperation of the men fighting within it. The focus of the film is the fights to such an extent that the final bout with Max Baer, maligned here as purely a mauler, lasts nearly half an hour. As with any Ron Howard movie the film looks superb, Howard having a visual eye which is often disregarded, and the recreation of the Depression-hit tenements certainly seems authentic if again a little too mannered and neat. Crowe is playing this almost on autopilot, and an actress like Renne Zellweger should be given better lines than she has here, in a role which is occasionally little more than an appendage to her husband, but there is some fine support in the form of Bruce McGill (Collateral / Legally Blonde 2), and Paul Giamatti (American Splendour / Man In The Moon), who predictably steals his scenes as Braddock's slippery manager Joe Gould. Braddock's story is a great one, and deserves this big-budget treatment, but as with A Beautiful Mind one starts to wonder about what has been taken out rather than what's been left in.