Film details

Shall We Dance?  2004

Film still

Cast

Synopsis

John Clark is a successful Chicago lawyer who nevertheless feels frustrated, both at work and at home, despite being seemingly happily married to Beverly, with children Jenna and Evan. Going home after leaving the office one evening he passes a dance class being taught by a Latino dance instructor, Paulina, and enrolls on impulse. In his first class he finds that one of the other pupils is Link, a work colleague. Beverly wonders why her husband is starting to return later and later from the office and suspects he is having an affair so employs Devine, a hard-bitten private detective, to follow him and discover just what is going on. Devine reports back, telling her of the dance classes, but Beverly does not reveal to John what she knows. Having taken classes under another teacher, John is surprised when Paulina takes a class he is in and the two become friendly. Beverly starts to notice that John is noticeibly happier and more communicative. Entering a novice competition and partnering a woman called Bobbie, John stumbles when he sees Beverly and Jenna in the audience, and Bobbie falls mid-dance. John goes home that night and apologises about keeping the classes from her but finds it hard to explain the pleasure he gets from dancing. Link's involvement is exposed in the office, causing other co-workers to ridicule him, but John comes out volubly to support him. He finds out from Link and Bobbie that Paulina is to go to England to study dance and they give him a note from her. It explains how she was dancing in competition in the World Championships in Blackpool when she fell, and it broke up her relationship with her partner, but seeing the pleasure he gets from it has re-awakened her enthusiasm for the art. She invites him to her leaving party and John is unsure what to do, until Beverly gives him her blessing, and more....

Production

Director
Peter Chelsom
Producer
Simon Fields
Art Director
Sue Chan
Editor
Charles Ireland
Music
John Altman
Screenplay
Audrey Wells, based on the original screenplay of the film Dansa Wo Shimasko Ka? by Masayuki Suo
Director of Photography
John De Borman

Review

Based on the 1996 Japanese film Shall We Dance, incidentally the most successful Japanese live-action film ever released in the US, this homogenised American remake is initially hampered by two major elements - firstly the fact that the lead of the original was a quiet, restrained and very ordinary salaryman, and certainly not the immaculate, drop dead gorgeous Richard Gere, and also that for the salaryman to be doing what he was doing by secretly taking dance classes was a genuine transgression in Japanese society, being seen not only as a betrayal to his family but also as something a little 'racy', close dancing being seen as a somewhat suspicious foreign import by older generations of Japanese. So what was originally a small and beautifully crafted tiny story has been blown up, expanded, and given added star power so that virtually everybody in the class, apart for those destined not to get a close-up, are perfectly coiffured with teeth a tiger shark would kill for. Which is a shame, since director Peter Chelsom has shown a deft touch for the offbeat with such films as Hear My Song and Funny Bones, his contributions to the utterly disastrous Town And Country not included since so little of the footage he originally shot remains in the finished item. Gere's character also lacks the motivation his Japanese counterpart had, explained in a speech not included in the US version, making Gere's impulse seem more like lechery than an urge to break free and do something liberating and unconventional. The film also makes it clear that there is very little chemistry between Gere's lawyer and Jennifer Lopez's dance instructor Paulina, since he's far too involved with his wife (Susan Sarandon) to get involved with another woman, which once again makes his motivation all the more baffling. It does however allow Chelsom to once more visit Blackpool, the setting for Funny Bones, for scenes at the World Ballroom Dancing Championship, and the fact that the northern town also featured in the Japanese version was one of the more surreal scenes in the film. Both leads are sadly overshadowed by the excellent Stanley Tucci (The Road To Perdition) as Link, Gere's co-worker who finds dancing so liberating he can even throw off his black wig to reveal his shiny pate. It's a daft moment but has the feeling of spontaneity and freedom the film as a whole so sorely lacks. Its' indicative of how American remakes are so ruthlessly planned but in adapting Dansa Wo Shimasko Ka? for an American audience, writer Audrey Wells has made something so predictable and, unlike something as vivacious as the samba or the tango, so safe.