Film details

Monster-in-Law  2005

Die Schwiegermonster
Film still

Cast

Synopsis

Charlotte 'Charlie' Cantalini is a California woman who fiercely keeps her independence by refusing to be tied down to any one job, juggling a number of temporary and part-time positions, despite her friends worrying that her full schedule means that Charlie, now in her thirties, is still alone, and shows no indications of changing any time soon. During her job as a dog-walker, she meets Kevin Fields, a wealthy doctor, and after the two seem to bump into each other an inordinate number times, they fall in love. While this is happening Kevin's mother, Viola, is trying unsuccessfully to cope with being ousted from her position as a TV anchorwoman by a younger woman, although the fact that she was becoming increasingly cranky and difficult on-screen with her interviewees didn't help. Viola is released from a care institution after having a complete breakdown. and is told by her assistant, Ruby, that her son will be bringing his new girlfriend, Charlie, to dinner. The moment Viola meets Charlie she is convinced that she is not worthy to be with her son, and when she finds that Kevin has proposed to her Viola is determined that she will break up their union, no matter what she has to do. Realising Charlie is unused to moving in the same monied and privileged world as Kevin, Viola tries everything to make her feel alienated and uncomfortable, but fails, so instead comes up with a plan to fake a severe anxiety attack just before Kevin has to fly to a very important medical conference, meaning Charlie will have to look after her until he comes back. Viola is determined to drive Charlie away, and acts appallingly, making increasingly impossible demands on her and insulting her every chance she can, but Charlie sticks to her task, and when he finds that Viola is faking her symptoms Charlie decides to turn the tables on her tormentor, believing that two can play at that particular game. Charlie is determined not to lose Kevin, the man of her dreams, but does not know that Viola is hiding her own particular dark secret, which will be revealed at the moment of maximum embarrassment....

Production

Director
Robert Luketic
Producer
Paula Weinstein, Chris Bender and J.C. Spink
Art Director
James F. Truesdale
Editor
Scott Hill and Kevin Tent
Music
David Newman
Screenplay
Anya Kochoff
Director of Photography
Russelll Carpenter

Review

The title may be blunt but is certainly honest in describing the character of Viola Fields, the resentful and outright demonic potential mother-in-law of Charlie Cantalini, setting up the premise of Monster-In-Law very succinctly, but while director Robert Luketic (Legally Blonde / Win A Date With Tad Hamilton) has perfect casting for Viola in the form of Jane Fonda, the first screen role for her since the uncomfortably mawkish Stanley & Iris in 1990, in having Jennifer Lopez (The Wedding Planner / Gigli) as Viola's prospective daughter-in-law, Luketic has essentially two divas going at each other in a fearsome struggle for screen domination, and while it never exactly reaches Whatever Happened To Baby Jane proportions, its' not only obvious to the audience that there's truly no love lost between those two monstrous egos, but also means that they really have no one to root for, the pushy and smug Charlie seeming to deserve every barb, swipe and snipe doled out to her. Although there are some clever and restrained passages, such as the first meeting between Viola and Charlie, over a seemingly civilised pot of tea on Viola's garden, the director is also prone to have them suddenly erupt in extremely broad physical comedy and pratfalls, such as Viola finally lashing out at yet another airhead teenage 'guest' on her chatshow, only there to push a product or film rather than actually give cogent answers, ending up brawling with her on the floor. While the two are obviously relishing the opportunity to snipe at each other on screen, and off if the set rumours were true, it is clear that Fonda, who still has terrific timing, is far more comfortable at sending up her own image than Lopez, Viola almost relishing her similarities to Sunset Boulevard's Norma Desmond, where as Lopez's Charlie is constantly being projected as the innocent party in all this, despite brief fantasy sequences in which she gets physical revenge on Viola, plunging her head into a cake at a party, even though Lopez's cold personality never makes her particularly sympathetic. Despite successfully making Viola a monster of Japanese city-wrecking proportions, debut scripter Anya Kochoff tortuously twists her script so that there is a happy but utterly convincing reconciliation in the final reel, despite all which has gone before, where a darker, edgier ending would have been far more fitting, and believable. Michael Vartan (Rogue / TV's Alias) plays Kevin, the male in the middle of these two, but its' a pretty thankless role since the film is so totally concerned with La Fonda and La Lopez, and don't they know it.