Film details
Dark Water 2005
Still unavailable
Cast
-
-
Ariel Gade
-
-
Dougray Scott
-
-
John C.Reilly
-
Camryn Manheim
-
Perla-Honey Jardine
-
Debra Monk
-
-
Bill Buell
-
Simon Reynolds
Synopsis
Having separated from her husband Lyle, New Yorker Dahlia Williams is in a custody battle over her daughter Ceci, which is getting progressively more unpleasant. Trying to find an apartment, Dahlia takes an apartment in a old and decrepit block, but Ceci likes the place. Managing to find a job in the neighbourhood, and putting Ceci in a kindergarten, she tries to cope with the custody hearings, believing Kyle is using tactics to make her seem irrational and disturbed, and weaken her case in keeping her daughter. Finding a dark water stain on the apartment ceiling, apparently coming from the apartment above, Dahlia asks the creepy Mr, Verck, the janitor, to do something about it, which he doesn't. Dahlia is told by Ceci's teacher that Ceci seems to have invented an imaginary friend, Natasha, the depth of her belief making the teacher uncomfortable. Large amounts of water start to come through Dahlia's ceiling, causing her to enter the upstairs apartment, which is empty but still has all the taps running. Mr. Varek blames mischevious children who live in the block and Dahlia finds the apartment is rented to absentee tenants, the Rimskys, Mrs. Rimsky being an alcoholic and her husband having returned to Russia. They had a daughter, Natasha, who vanished years previously. Dahlia starts to worry about Ceci and her imaginary friend, believing it to be too much of a coincidence. Hiring a lawyer, Jeff Platzer, to deal with the custody case, Platzer realises that the strain of what is happening at home is deeply affecting Dahlia, and does a little investigating of his own. Ceci seems to be suffering as well, and Dahlia tries a compromise deal with her ex-husband, sharing custody and also moving to nearer his neighbourhood. Led by a strange little girl, who she believes may be the missing Natasha, Dahlia ventures onto the roof and to the water tower on top, where a little girl's body is found. When the Police contact the Rimskys they find that each parent believed the little girl was with the other one, when in fact she had drowned. Dahlia believes the mystery of Natasha, and perhaps Ceci's disturbances, is over, but Natasha has found the surrogate mother she wants to be with forever, and will not let her leave.....
Production
- Director
- Walter Salles
- Producer
- Roy Lee, Bill Mechanic and Doug Davison
- Art Director
- Nicholas Lundy and Andrew M.Stearn
- Editor
- Daniel Rezende
- Music
- Angelo Badalamanti
- Screenplay
- Rafael Yglesias, based on the screenplay of the 2002 film Dark Water / Honogurai Mizu No Soko Kara by Yoshihiro Nakamura and Kenichi Suzuki, directed by Hideo Nakata, based on the novel by Koji Suzuki
- Director of Photography
- Alfonso Beato
Review
The J-Horror craze has been a Godsend to an increasingly moribund American horror market, with US remakes of The Ring and The Grudge being not only successful but also spawning their own, stand-alone sequels, in not being derived from the Japanese follow-ups or franchise entries. The American Ring Two went so far as to have the original Japanese director, and one of the fathers of the J-Horror boom Hideo Nakata, as helmer after the original director, some forgettable music video refugee, dropped out, and Dark Water is a remake of another Nakata original. Although sticking reasonably closely to the original, some accommodations have been made in this version directed by the very well-regarded Walter Salles (Central Station / The Motorcycle Diaries). Jennifer Connelly's Dahila is a far more seemingly stable character than her Japanese counterpart, and the building is less initially scary, Nakata's version being a building only the desperate or the partially deranged would want or need to inhabit. Nakata's film also brought the character of the missing child into the proceedings much earlier, tipping off the audience but also providing the background for some effective visuals, such as a little girl's clutchbag, decorated with an increasingly creepy-looking rabbit, which seemed to repeatedly turn up, no matter how many times it was thrown away in the rubbish. Salles beefs up the male roles, with John C. Reilly (Chicago) as a pushy real estate agent, and Dougray Scott in a much larger role as the husband, of which little was known in the Japanese version, making the central female character seem more isolated and threatened, and the always reliable Pete Postlethwaite as the building's suitably unsettling caretaker. Once again Hollywood has changed the ending, but at least Salles' version does not go for the upbeat, everything's OK again which so scuppered remakes such as George Sluizer's US version of his own The Vanishing, which utterly destroyed the shattering impact of the original, but Salles at least goes for something thematically in keeping with the original Japanese film, if not quite as grim as Nakata's version, losing some of the elements of self-sacrifice. Nakata's film is still the more chilling, but Salles has made a very strong drama which only lurches into dark territory in the final reels.